Travis Goldman is one of the main contributors for pinstripealley, which is another Yankees blog site. I decided to ask him a few questions and give his perspective on the Yankees’ 2010 season.
Me: I was wondering if I could get your perspective on the Yankees’ offseason trades and signings. Do you think they should have tried to make other moves?
Travis: Considering Johnny Damon and Hideki Matsui will earn $14 million this year while Curtis Granderson and Nick Johnson will earn about $11 million, and that the departed players are a combined 12 years older, there’s not much to dislike about those particular moves. Grandy should bounce back from a sub-par ’09, and if Johnson stays healthy (and he should, as the primary DH), he’ll produce just fine.
On the pitching side, I would have preferred John Lackey to Javy Vazquez, but all things considered (price, durability, flexibility), I can’t really complain. Lackey is a great pitcher, but so is Vazquez. The question is how much did the Yanks give up? Melky Cabrera is a nice, solid player, and Phil Coke is a decent reliever, but the ‘winner’ of the trade will hinge on super pitching-prospect Arodys Vizcaino. Is giving up those three players for a year of Vazquez better than signing Lackey for five years (and losing a first-round pick)? It’s an unanswerable question right now.
Me: I was wondering who you think we, the fans, (and Yankee management too I suppose) should watch in the upcoming year.
Travis: Dave Robertson could become one of the better set-up men in baseball if he builds on last year: he has a damn good fastball and a great curve – all he needs is to consistently throw them where he wants to.
The other is Jesus Montero, who has an outside chance to be the DH or BUC in the second half if injuries or ineffectiveness occur.
Me: There are a few jobs up for grabs this spring, including the 3rd outfield spot and most importantly, the 5th spot in the starting rotation. Who do you think SHOULD get these jobs?
Travis: The third OF spot should go to Brett Gardner (over Randy Winn) for a variety of reasons: he’s a better defender, runs the bases better, and should be no worse as a hitter. He’s also a decade younger. Furthering that, he should be the everyday CFer over Granderson. While Grandy is a solid CFer, Gardy is truly an exceptional one, thanks to his blazing speed. And having Grandy signed for another four years (at $37 million) makes him a more ‘delicate’ asset (at least compared to the minimum-making Gardner), so playing the less-demanding LF should ensure Grandy’s longterm viability.
The fifth starter’s a bit tougher. Honestly, both Hughes and Joba deserve to start, but I’ll give the nod to Joba. He has no innings cap this year (unlike Hughes) and had to endure two years on ‘training wheels’ just for this opportunity. He deserves the chance to start for a full year. If Hughes is a reliever the whole year, I worry what will happen to him. A reliever won’t top 100 innings, so he can’t be expected to hit 200 in 2011 (if Vazquez or Pettitte leave), and he’s too good to be a reliever for his career. You have to wonder if they’ll send him to Scranton to build up his innings at some point (but I know Hughes wouldn’t be happy getting ‘demoted’). It’ll be a challenge for Girardi, Cashman and Co., but that’s why they get paid the big bucks.